Page 1 of 1
Eggs Without Shells - Is It Lack of Oyster Shell or Just Growing Pains?
Posted: Sat Feb 01, 2025 6:55 am
by CoopConnoisseur
I have a mixed flock of Easter Eggers, Red Stars, and one Red Cochin Bantam (who I've never seen lay an egg). They were all hatched in May and started laying around November to December. Recently, I've encountered a problem three times with messes in the nesting box, including an egg today that had no shell, just yolk and whites.
I feed them Purina Layer Crumbles with the Oyster Strong system logo, but I'm wondering if this could be due to a lack of oyster shell or if it's just because they are still young. Any advice or insights would be greatly appreciated! Thanks!

Re: Eggs Without Shells - Is It Lack of Oyster Shell or Just Growing Pains?
Posted: Sun Feb 02, 2025 5:35 am
by BroodyBella
It's likely just growing pains. Young layers often have occasional soft-shell or shell-less eggs as they start laying. Make sure they have access to grit and oyster shell to support their calcium needs.
Re: Eggs Without Shells - Is It Lack of Oyster Shell or Just Growing Pains?
Posted: Tue Feb 04, 2025 12:48 pm
by EggsAndGiggles
I'd recommend monitoring their diet closely. While Purina Layer Crumbles should offer good nutrition, sometimes a little extra calcium, like oyster shell, could help prevent soft-shell or shell-less eggs.
Re: Eggs Without Shells - Is It Lack of Oyster Shell or Just Growing Pains?
Posted: Tue Feb 04, 2025 9:41 pm
by DownyDreamkeeper
I had the same issue with my flock when they were starting out. It seems to be more common in young layers. Keep an eye on them, and you may see improvement as they mature.
Re: Eggs Without Shells - Is It Lack of Oyster Shell or Just Growing Pains?
Posted: Tue Feb 04, 2025 10:16 pm
by ChickMagnet
It could be a mix of both. Sometimes young hens take a bit of time to fully adjust to laying and may produce soft-shelled eggs. The Purina feed should be fine, but offering extra oyster shell on the side can help.
Re: Eggs Without Shells - Is It Lack of Oyster Shell or Just Growing Pains?
Posted: Thu Feb 06, 2025 8:16 am
by FeatheredGuardian
It sounds like a calcium deficiency. Even with Purina Layer Crumbles, adding oyster shell can help your hens' bodies build stronger eggs. Consider providing it in a separate dish so they can help themselves.